Council Members

  1. Carter Nevill


    Expiration of term: December 31, 2026

    A Warrenton native, Carter spent much time growing up on Main Street where his parents owned and operated the Stable Door for 35 years. While a student at the University of Virginia, he worked as a  ladder runner and dishwasher in the kitchen of the C&O Restaurant. After graduating he remained in Charlottesville working in restaurants until a departure into the wine world led him to become the Southeast Regional Sales Manager for the leading importer of South African wines, Cape Classics. During this time, he met and married Kathleen who had apprenticed as a bench jeweler and then managed a specialty fine jewelry store. Following Kathleen's dream to open her own business, the couple returned to Warrenton in 2004 and opened Carter and Spence, Ltd. in the former home of Hurst Jewelers on Main Street. Both Carter and Kathleen remain active in Old Town and greater Warrenton/Fauquier preservation organizations. The couple has a son, Hugh, and 3 dogs named Whiskers, Rocky and Dusty.

  1. Paul Mooney

    At-Large Council Member

    Expiration of term: December 31, 2026

    Councilman Paul Mooney is a husband and father of four, a local small business owner, and a Marine Corps reservist.  

    Paul is passionate about his community and wants to ensure it stays a place where families, individuals, and democracy can thrive.  

    A heart for service is something Paul grew up with and his large extended family is oriented toward: Paul’s father, two of his brothers and five of his brothers-in-law have served or are serving in the U.S. military, with one brother-in-law serving in local law enforcement.  

    As a well-traveled college student and Marine (29 countries), an older sibling in a large family, and a multi-business owner, Paul has seen many different cultures and personalities and looks to use this experience as a council member to bring all people together.  

    Paul is a fiscal conservative and believes in a representative government that is transparent and works for the best interest and will of the people.  

    It is the distinct honor and privilege of him and his wife, Kelly – who was raised in Warrenton, Virginia – to serve the residents of this wonderful town and community.  

  1. David McGuire

    At-Large Council Member

    Expiration of term:  December 31, 2026

    David McGuire's family has 100 years of service in law enforcement. His father and uncles served in combat during World War II. David spent over 28 years in public service as a police officer and Army officer. As a police officer with specialized military training after 9/11 he was called to serve in combat during The Global War on Terrorism. Some of his assignments include The Pentagon Joint Staff and The Republic of Korea. He was awarded The Legion of Merit Medal for his service. 

    David believes that public service is noble and necessary, to be served with integrity, faith, and family. It is a way to give back to the community. A fiscal conservative, he believes in the transparency of government. The primary responsibility of a town council member is to listen and be a voice for the citizens. To have integrity in all his actions both public and private. Putting the citizens and the town first in everything he will do as council member. 

    David has a master’s degree in history from Norwich University. He is an avid equestrian, and he volunteers with local civic and veterans’ organizations in his spare time.

  1. Heather D. Sutphin

    Ward 1 Council Member

    Expiration of term:  December 31, 2024 

    Heather Grimsley Sutphin has been in the real estate business since 2013, and is currently a Real Estate Agent with Century 21 New Millennium.  After a three year career in Law Enforcement at the Fauquier County Sheriff's office, she started a lengthy career in marketing and advertising.  She has helped numerous businesses with their marketing through print, television, and radio.

    An active member of the Fauquier County Chamber of Commerce, HGBA, and a past member of the Culpeper Chamber of Commerce, she has also been very active with volunteering within the community.  She was a past board member of the Fauquier Historical Society, also helping with the Boys and Girls Club, a supporter of the Warrenton Town Police, a current member of the Silent Auction Committee with the Warrenton Horse Show, past committee member of the Town Transportation and Safety Committee.

    Heather and her husband Wendell enjoy living in Warrenton.  In their free time, they love to attend the different local events and going for long walks with their pitbull Gracie.  Heather also enjoys hiking, the beach, spending time with her granddaughter and friends.

  1. William T. Semple II

    Ward 2 Council Member

    Expiration of term: December 31, 2024

    Bill Semple is a retired entrepreneur, businessman and Navy veteran best known for inventing and successfully licensing mapping programs now used by practically everyone who uses a smartphone, laptop, or computer. Bill began his career in life, health and annuity sales and then shifted to non-profit development, marketing, public relations, strategic planning, and operational benchmarking. In 1994, he invented and for the next twenty-two years oversaw the licensing of his “local search” technology to dozens of Fortune 500 companies, during which time he served as chief financial officer of a technology company. In addition to having won numerous awards for his community service, Bill is an avid clarinetist and member of the Fauquier Community Band. He also plays in the pit orchestra for Highland’s School musical productions. Bill and his wife Sally live with their poodle Sophie in a 1900 Victorian that Sally purchased in 1994. Sally raised her two children, Emily and Nathan in this home and credits much of their success and happiness to the safe environment Warrenton provided. As a consequence, Sally and Bill share an avid commitment to preserving the Warrenton they love. 

  1. Brett A. Hamby

    Ward 3 Council Member

    Expiration of Term: December 31, 2024

    Councilman Hamby was born and raised in Fauquier County and has resided in the Town of Warrenton for almost thirty years. He has worked for Prince William Fire and Rescue for 25 years and currently, is a Battalion Chief. Councilman Hamby is also a lifetime member of the Warrenton Volunteer Fire Department.  In his spare time, he enjoys the outdoors and likes to fish. It is his distinct honor to serve and continue to serve the residents of Ward 3.

  1. James N. Hartman III

    Vice Mayor, Ward 4 Council Member

    Expiration of Term: December 31, 2024

    Councilman Jimmy Hartman is a lifelong Warrenton resident, representing Ward 4 as his father did in the 1980’s.  Councilman Hartman is proud to have served in law enforcement for over 31 years and retired in 2020.  He is a graduate of the FBI National Academy and DEA Drug Unit Commanders Academy and is a past treasurer of Fauquier Cops For Children.  

    Councilman Hartman has volunteered with many organizations throughout the years most recently serving on the Board of Directors of the Boys and Girls Clubs of Fauquier. 

    Councilman Hartman is currently employed at Fauquier County Public Schools.  He enjoys living in Warrenton and working to preserve the unique character and charm of our small town and the quality of life in Ward 4.  

  1. John B. "Jay" Heroux III

    Ward 5 Council Member

    Expiration of Term: December 31, 2024

    Jay Heroux is a long-time resident of Warrenton Ward 5; having moved here in 1994. He and his wife Jill raised their three sons and dog named Willie here in Warrenton.  He currently is a member of the PATH Foundation Community Advisory Committee;   Board Member for Ethnos College located in Warrenton and a volunteer for the Fauquier Free Clinic.  For many years he was a hockey coach and President of the Fauquier County Roller Hockey League located at the Warrenton Athletic Complex.   Jay is a Community Deacon at Warrenton Baptist Church. He is one of the founders of the Warrenton Baptist Church Rooted Motel Ministry as well as an active member of the Wood Ministry.  Jay is also a volunteer Chaplain at Fauquier Hospital.  

    Jay is currently a Vice President at Definitive Logic Corp where he is responsible for developing and executing clients’ digital transformation technology projects. Prior to this role, he helped build Digital Mobilizations Inc, a Fauquier County technology services firm that was acquired in 2022 by Definitive Logic. He spent close to 20 great years working for Electronic Data Systems which was acquired by Hewlett Packard Corp. During his time there, he worked on several groundbreaking technology modernization programs. He has applied his technology knowledge to industries including healthcare, defense, telecommunications, manufacturing, pharmaceuticals, and logistics. Jay has a BA in Public Administration from Stonehill College in North Easton MA.